 | Barry Pepper Roger Maris |
 | Thomas Jane Mickey Mantle |
 | Anthony Michael Hall Whitey Ford |
 | Richard Masur Milt Kahn |
 | Bruce McGill Ralph Houk |
 | Chris Bauer Bob Cerv |
 | Jennifer Crystal Foley Pat Maris ('61) |
 | Christopher McDonald Mel Allen |
 | Haynes Brooke Detroit Bartender |
 | Bob Gunton Dan Topping |
 | Donald Moffat Ford Frick |
 | Joe Grifasi Phil Rizzuto |
 | Peter Jacobson Artie Green |
 | Seymour Cassel Sam Simon |
 | Robert Joy Bob Fitschel |
 | Michael Nouri Joe DiMaggio |
 | Domenick Lombardozzi Moose Skowron |
 | Bobby Hosea Elston Howard |
 | Paul Borghese Yogi Berra |
 | Renée Taylor Claire Ruth |
 | Pat Crowley Pat Maris |
 | Dane Northcutt Randy Maris |
 | Charles Esten Kevin Maris |
 | Shannah Laumeister Stern Pretty Young Woman |
 | Shiva Rose Toot's Girl |
 | Mike Carlucci Memorial Stadium Announcer (voice) |
 | Tony Stef'Ano Baseball Fan (uncredited) |
| Mark McGwire Self (uncredited)(archived footage) |
 | Sammy Sosa Self (uncredited)(archived footage) |
| Brynne McNabb Susan Maris ('61) |
| Cameryn McNabb Susan Maris ('61) |
| Writing | |
| Hank Steinberg | Writer |
Directing | |
| Billy Crystal | Director |
Camera | |
| Haskell Wexler | Director of Photography |
Production | |
| Carl S. Griffin | Line Producer |
Editing | |
| Michael Jablow | Editor |
Art | |
| Rusty Smith | Production Design |
Sound | |
| Marc Shaiman | Original Music Composer |
Art | |
| Anne D. McCulley | Set Decoration |
Costume & Make-Up | |
| Dan Moore | Costume Design |
Production | |
| Billy Crystal | Executive Producer |
Art | |
| Denise Hudson | Art Direction |
Production | |
| Robert F. Colesberry | Producer |
| Ross Greenburg | Executive Producer |
| Mali Finn | Casting |
